The daily “Zhoghovurd” reported that trees in the forest next to one of Lake Sevan’s public beaches were cut at a height of about two meters. According to the Ministry of Environment’s clarification, no felling took place; sanitary pruning was carried out. The two accounts don’t contradict each other as much as it may seem, but questions remain that haven’t yet been answered.
What the newspaper claims. The site is on the Sevan\u2013Dilijan highway, before the “Harsnaqar” restaurant. In the newspaper’s photographs, it says, the forest is “literally beheaded.” Sevan National Park replied by phone that the trees were leaning and that the ministry had approved the program. The paper notes that only a few trees in the wooded stretch were leaning; the rest were straight. It asks what professional conclusion the program was approved on, who assessed the damage, and why the trees were cut at that height. It also contrasts the situation with the speeches on nature protection made during COP17.
What the ministry replies. What took place was sanitary pruning, not felling, and it happened months ago. The trees are poplars planted in the 1950s\u201360s, some of which are overmature, leaning, have lost vitality and pose a danger to visitors and businesses. Before pruning, the national park and professional working groups carried out studies, inventory and assessment, and the work was done under the procedure set by the ministry. After pruning, the trees form a new crown, which increases their vitality.
Where the accounts differ.
- Method. Sanitary pruning usually means removing dead, diseased or hazardous branches. Cutting at about two meters is a far more severe intervention, and for mature trees the method is considered debatable among specialists. The ministry’s clarification gives no justification for choosing it.
- The trees’ condition. The newspaper says few were leaning; the ministry says they are overmature and dangerous. This can be checked against inventory records, which have not been published.
- Timing. The ministry says “months ago”; the newspaper gives no date.
What could settle the dispute. Publishing the tree inventory and assessment records, the permit and the ministry’s approved procedure, stating the number and condition of trees cut or pruned, and a visit by an independent forester or arborist. In spring it will also become clear whether the trees really do form new crowns.
Sevan’s shore is a sensitive zone, and public trust here calls for documentary transparency more than a short clarification.
Sources:
https://www.facebook.com/share/1ap5gxYSby/
https://news.am/hy/news/1076033